So What?


I can hear the whining all the way out here on Vancouver Island.

There is a constant refrain from Oiler fans that the officials are letting the Oilers opponents get away with murder and that the Oilers should have more powerplay opportunities than they get.

That all culminated in last night’s assault by Darnell Nurse on Roman Polak which, viewed objectively,  should not have involved a penalty to Polak when Matt Hendricks lost his balance and crashed into the boards. That was followed, of course, by Nurse seeking retribution for which, by the rule book he should have received 2 minutes for instigating, 5 minutes for fighting, a game misconduct for instigating in the last 5 minutes and an automatic one game suspension.

That things did not play out that way hasn’t dented the blood lust by most Oiler fans who now are seeing this as a watershed moment after which the Oilers will no longer be pushed around and will hard to play against.

Of course that is nonsense and I would imagine San Jose will set the Oilers straight in the next meeting later this month.

The Evidence

But let’s examine the notion that the Oilers would be a more successful team if the on ice officials just called the penalties that they should against their opponents.

While I agree that NHL officiating can be very inconsistent and sometimes spiteful (see Stephane Auger’s vendetta against Alex Burrows), after watching almost every minute of Oiler games this year, I don’t see any more inconsistency than you can see nightly in other games.

While I think it’s true that veteran teams get a little “benefit of the doubt” non calls from the refs, I’m not sure that the volume or result of calling Oiler games strictly by the book would make much difference in any event.

As luck would have it, Sporting Charts tracks penalties throughout the league and provides us with some context.

Screen Shot 2016-03-09 at 2.14.37 PM.png

As you can see, the Oilers DO rank near the bottom of the number of power plays/game but with 196 PP opportunities, they are only 18 behind the median of 214 received by the Dallas Stars.


Let’s assume for a moment that the Oilers got a league average of power play opportunities and then let’s take a look at what that would actually mean.

The Oilers power play percentage is currently 16.8%, so, if they got an additional 18 calls, they would have scored exactly 3 additional goals this season.

No telling where or when those goals would have been scored, whether in a tight game or a blowout but I can’t see those 3 goals resulting in any more than 1 additional win.

And that folks would mean absolutely nothing in the big picture.

If Oiler fans want their power play to make a difference then they should focus their attention on how bad Todd McLellan’s powerplay is and stop whining about officiating.




3 thoughts on “So What?

  1. “While I agree that NHL officiating can be very inconsistent and sometimes spiteful (see Stephane Auger’s vendetta against Alex Burrows)”

    Really? Alex Burrows should be a target!

    This guy has pulled hair – spit on a guy – Bit a guy – Kicked a guy – Used a derogatory raciest comment on a player – dirty head hits – sucker punches – Dives – call’s out officials……..just a few of the duchebaggery this player does on a game to game basis.

    The guy is a tool.

    Honestly, poor choice of players, embarreses a refreee, calls him out and wonders why they target him….Good grief.

    Nurse crossed then line and did it a little recklessly. However, he will be suspended and will step up when SJS comes looking for retribution, Nurse will stand in there and take his lumps.

    Burrows would do no such thing.

    To a man, the Oilers have been far to easy to play against, to many times teammates turn there back and skate off into the sunset when shit starts going down.

    For the first time since Souray left the Oilers they have a little crazy on the team……Absolutly nothing wrong with crossing the line once in a while to show teams that its not so easy anymore…..

    He’s going to get suspended and he should be for a couple reasons.


    1. Well, the 3 games seem about right.

      Now, the issue for Nurse is that he has a history and will have to be very careful about stepping over the line again.

      That negates any good his actions may have produced.


      1. Thats a really good point.

        He will have to be careful but I still think standing up for your teammates is a prority on the Oilers and Nurse has a team coming after him.

        I want to see if he stands in there and takes his licks. I might have a new found respect for the player.


Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s